Skip to main content
Rainbow BridgeCompassionate Pet Aftercare Guide
Find ServicesGuide & CostAquamationMemorial Shop
For BusinessFind Gentle Care
Rainbow Bridge

Helping pet families find compassionate aftercare services across the United States.

Need immediate help?

Find 24/7 Services →

Services

  • Pet Cremation
  • Aquamation
  • Pet Burial

Resources

  • Pet Loss Guide
  • Cost Guide
  • Grief Support

Company

  • Find Services
  • For Business
  • Memorial Shop

© 2026 The Rainbow Bridge Guide. Made with love for our furry friends.

ResourcesAll StatesFor ProvidersPrivacy
HomeOhioColumbusRutherford Funeral Homes & Crematories

Rutherford Funeral Homes & Crematories

3.3(10 reviews)
450 W Olentangy St, Columbus, OH 43065
Estimated: $150 - $450
Call (614) 792-1471Visit Website

Is this your business?

Claim for Free →

About Rutherford Funeral Homes & Crematories

Rutherford Funeral Homes & Crematories is a trusted pet aftercare provider dedicated to serving families in Columbus, OH. Known for their compassionate, understanding, highly recommended approach to pet loss care, they offer memorial products and keepsakes. As one family shared: "This has to be one of the worst experiences at a funeral home that I have ever encountered and I..." With a 3.3-star ra

Services Offered

Memorial Products

Reviews

10 reviews
B
Bob Doerr
March 15, 2025

This has to be one of the worst experiences at a funeral home that I have ever encountered and I have been to many, many funerals. On the evening of the calling hours, we had been waiting about 45 minutes and the line behind us was growing. The funeral director took it upon himself to split the receiving line. This was a terrible idea because now people who had only been waiting perhaps 10-15 minutes were now at the head of the second receiving line, while those of us who had been waiting continued to wait. And then if all of that wasn't bad enough, the lines were now supposed to alternate embracing the grieving family, but instead the grieving family now felt obligated to split up and have a person or persons at the head of each line. The end result? The people we came to consul were now in the other line and we never had the opportunity to get anywhere near them. The next day for the funeral we pulled into the parking lot and were not greeted or given any instructions as to how to park or proceed depending on if we were going to the cemetery afterwards. Everyone just parked wherever they wanted and the end of the service we were told to just turn on your lights and flashers and get in line, except no one was giving any directions on where the line was forming. All in all, I would never send anyone to this funeral home for their sheer lack of preparedness and somewhat rudeness during a very difficult time for so many.

J
Julie Cowher
September 14, 2024

For those interested in learning about and developing Preneed Funeral Services, I recommend setting up an appointment with MacKenzie Dunn. Patience, knowledge, and compassion were always present. Thank you, Kenzie.

D
Deb Foley
December 10, 2019

Our funeral directory, Barb Fortkamp, was fantastic. She was compassionate, understanding, knowledgeable and helped make the experience the best it could be. They took care of everything. I would highly recommend Barb and Rutherford.

B
Brent L Harper
May 30, 2024

The Powell location website says 5:00 close, but I called to verify a person tells me 4:00. The last time (2yrs ago) I was told someone would be there, they left early for an unexpected training meeting!

M
Matt Mollica
October 28, 2022

We highly recommend Rutherford and specifically Todd. We worked with Todd during a horrible time. Todd was a great help and helped us navigate numerous issues with his knowledge and care. We couldn't be happier with Rutherford and Todd. Thanks again.

Helpful Resources

  • Aquamation vs Cremation →
  • Pet Cremation Cost Guide →
  • Coping with Pet Loss →

Other Providers in Columbus

View all providers in Columbus